By Lawrence Hurley

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled in a case concerning alcohol regulations enacted following the Prohibition era that Tennessee residency requirements for liquor retailers violate the U.S. Constitution’s interstate commerce provision.

The 7-2 ruling held that Tennessee’s regulations unlawfully discriminated against out-of-state businesses in violation of the Constitution’s so-called Commerce Clause.

The case pitted two constitutional provisions against one another: the 21st Amendment, which repealed the 18th Amendment ban on alcohol, and the Commerce Clause, which prevents states from discriminating against out-of-state businesses.

The state law imposed a two-year in-state residency requirement for business owners applying for a license and 10-year residency requirements for license renewals.

“Because Tennessee’s two-year residency requirement for retail license applicants blatantly favors the state residents and has little relationship to public health and safety, it is unconstitutional,” conservative Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the court.

The 21st Amendment explicitly gave states the power to regulate alcohol sales within their borders. But Supreme Court rulings regarding the Commerce Clause prevent states from discriminating against out-of-state businesses. The court in 2005 ruled that states could not let in-state wineries ship wine to consumers but prevent out-of-state wineries from doing so.

Conservative justices Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas dissented, with Gorsuch writing that the 21st Amendment allows for regulations like those in Tennessee.

“Like it or not, those who adopted the 21st Amendment took the view that reasonable people can disagree about the costs and benefits of free trade in alcohol,” Gorsuch wrote.

Maryland-based Total Wine and More, a major retailer that operates 193 stores in 23 states, was one of the challengers. Total Wine’s co-founder and co-owner David Trone won election in November to the U.S. House of Representatives as a Democrat from Maryland.

The case began when a state-level trade association urged Tennessee officials in 2016 to reject liquor license applications from Total Wine and a couple who recently arrived from Utah and wanted to open a liquor store.

Tennessee’s alcohol regulator preemptively filed suit seeking a declaration that the state regulations were lawful, but lower courts ruled against the state.

A separate provision that effectively prevented out-of-state retailers for opening stores was struck down by a lower court and was not at issue in the Supreme Court ruling.

The Supreme Court argument in the case on Jan. 16 came on the 100th anniversary of the ratification of the Constitution’s 18th Amendment, which imposed a nationwide ban on alcoholic beverages and paved the way for a Prohibition era that ran from 1920 to 1933.

Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham

Affiliate News Feeds

  • Washington Examiner
  • The Federalist
  • The Epoch Times
  • The Guardian
  • The Gateway Pundit

Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-TX) said he has told President Joe Biden many times that the United States needs to take more aggressive action at the southern border as illegal immigrants… [...]

U.S. natural gas industry leaders are amping up calls for the Biden administration and other governments to embrace the energy source ahead of a tough winter for much of the… [...]

Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin defended his administration's model policies on transgender students, saying the previous policies "excluded parents" after a day of student protests at numerous public schools. [...]

Ohio Democrat Rep. Tim Ryan sounds a lot different running for Senate than he did running for president. [...]

Historical setbacks and the proliferation of broken homes hurt black Americans, but there’s also something else: Marxism.  [...]

A woman’s death in Iran has sparked mass protests but little response from the Biden administration or ‘the squad’ of congresswomen. [...]

The Epoch Times sat down with Bernie Rivers, the Democrat candidate for Orange County Sheriff at his campaign office in Goshen, New York, on Sept. 26. Rivers, the sole Democrat… [...]

House Democrats have released their long-awaited bill to ban stock trading by members of Congress, senior government officials, and U.S. Supreme Court justices, with the legislation seeking to cut conflicts of… [...]

WASHINGTON—Many prospective jurors questioned on Tuesday and Wednesday for the Oath Keepers trial say they can be impartial despite having strong views on the Jan. 6, 2021, breach of the… [...]

No 10 says PM has faith in chancellor, as Treasury minister says tax cuts are the ‘right plan’Q: When would you get debt falling as a proprotion of GDP?Starmer says… [...]

MPs express disbelief over sterling slump as privately some fear PM’s ‘government is dead on arrival’Liz Truss is facing growing pressure from jittery Conservative MPs to sack Kwasi Kwarteng or… [...]

Opposition leaders urge PM and chancellor to take action over economic fallout and recall parliamentPolitics live – latest updatesDowning Street is resisting pressure to recall parliament, with Liz Truss and… [...]

Law enforcement is currently responding to a reported active shooter situation at the St. Vincent North Hospital, in Sherwood, Arkansas. At least one person is dead, according to a report… [...]

Lizzo has become the only person to ever be allowed to play the flute owned by James Madison, which was loaned to her by the Library of Congress. The 200-year-old… [...]

This was awkward. Joe Biden on Wednesday delivered remarks from the Rose Garden to celebrate the Americans with Disabilities Act and mark Disability Pride Month. Dr. Jill had to tell… [...]

NH Politician

NH POLITICIAN is owned and operated by USNN World News Corporation, a New Hampshire based media company specializing in the collection, publication and distribution of public opinion information, local,...