Meet the people who will decide the outcome of the 2020 Elections.


THE DECIDERS

Meet the voters defining America’s politics

By Letitia Stein 
Photography by Brian Snyder

Supporters of President Trump wave to passing drivers in the Pinellas County city of Clearwater, Florida.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

A retiree worried about his granddaughter’s future in Pinellas County, Florida. A factory worker in Racine County, Wisconsin, who doubts politicians will improve her life as a single mother.

A Boy Scout leader willing to cross party lines to revive his blue-collar town in Northampton County, Pennsylvania. A gay, Latino college student in Maricopa County, Arizona, preparing to cast his first presidential ballot.

These voters live in some of the most competitive counties in America’s presidential battleground states, places set to play an outsized role in the 2020 presidential election. All four counties were decided by four percentage points or less in 2016 and ultimately won by Donald Trump.

Trump’s path to a second term will test an electoral map he realigned. He must hold the strong support of the white, working-class voters who helped him capture Florida and Pennsylvania.

He will aim to build on his narrow victory in Wisconsin, which saw a decline in turnout among predominately Democratic black voters. And he is fighting to keep the onetime Republican stronghold of Arizona in his column as population shifts have put the state in play for Democrats.

Reuters will report from four critical counties in these states through the election for a better understanding of the people and places defining the presidential race.

The series starts with the stories of four people whose voting decisions – often driven by personal experiences, they said, rather than by party affiliation – continue to upend politics as usual.

THE COUNTIES

Reuters selected the counties in this series after examining, among other factors, voting patterns, demographics, population trends and economic statistics for more than 700 U.S. counties across a total of seven states that political strategists expect to be closely fought.

Pinellas County, Florida

This sprawling county on Florida’s central west coast voted for Trump by about 1 percentage point, a razor-thin margin in a state where elections are always tight. Though Democrats won the county comfortably in the 2008 and 2012 White House races, it now includes almost the same number of registered Democrats and Republicans.View John Lenges’ story

Racine County, Wisconsin

This county in the southeastern part of the state picked the winner of the last five U.S. presidential elections, going for Trump by 4 percentage points in 2016. A controversial multi-billion-dollar Foxconn manufacturing plant now under construction here is lauded by Trump as a chance to rebuild American manufacturing.View Stacy Baugh’s story

Northampton County, Pennsylvania

This predominantly white county is becoming more racially diverse even as it flipped to the Republicans in 2016. Trump captured Northampton County by 4 percentage points after Democrats won it in the four prior presidential elections.View Kurt Zuhlke’s story

Maricopa County, Arizona

Hispanic voters are a growing electoral force in the largest, most politically influential county of a state on the U.S.-Mexico border. In 2016, Trump’s 3-percentage point edge in Maricopa was the closest for a Republican president in years. In 2018, U.S. Senator Kyrsten Sinema, a Democrat, secured her win by flipping the county.View Alexis Rodriguez’s story

FLORIDA



PINELLAS COUNTY

POP. 975,280

People play shuffleboard at the St. Petersburg Shuffleboard Club, which began in 1924, in St. Petersburg, Florida.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

I’d like to give him at least another four years.

John Lenges, 65

John Lenges held four fingers in the air, cheering as a Florida crowd chanted “four more years” at this month’s opening rally for Trump’s 2020 re-election campaign.

Four years earlier, when Trump announced his presidential bid, Lenges was a Democrat. He mostly tuned out politics. He had never voted for a Republican president. Trump was different – a businessman and political outsider.

John Lenges, who changed parties to vote Republican in 2016, and his sister Jeanne Coffin talk at the conclusion of President Trump’s re-election campaign kick-off rally in Orlando, Florida.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

“It was a wakeup call,” said Lenges, 65, a retired maintenance supervisor. “Our country needed a turn.”

Lenges worries about his granddaughter’s future as he hears daily news reports of violence. He hates seeing the removal of statues honoring Confederate soldiers who fought in the U.S. Civil War, saying it trashes history.

Trump may not solve every problem, Lenges said, “but I think he’s a start.”

PAST PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION RESULTS

DEMOCRAT

50%

REPUBLICANPinellas County47.5%48.6%2016Florida47.8%49.0%Pinellas County52.2%46.6%2012Florida50.0%49.1%Pinellas County53.6%45.3%2008Florida51.0%48.2%Pinellas County49.5%49.6%2004Florida47.1%52.1%

Friends called him crazy when he started waving handmade Trump signs around Pinellas County, where retirees, suburbanites and urban hipsters share sugar-sand beaches, and the electorate swings between the two major political parties in presidential contests.

He collects Trump memorabilia. His framed ticket to Trump’s inauguration hangs on a home office wall once dedicated to auto racing.

John Lenges displays his toy “Build the Wall” set at his home in Largo, Florida.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

Lenges joined the Democratic Party when his father’s job as an assistant fire chief in Indiana depended on the party’s patronage. He remained loyal after moving to Florida and throughout his years raising his two sons to appreciate American eagles, motorcycles and the proper technique for skinning hogs.

TOP: A U.S. flag flies from the back of a truck on the Courtney Campbell Causeway Beach in Clearwater, Florida. BOTTOM LEFT: A supporter of President Trump has “TRUMP” spelled out on her fingernails during a roadside sign waving rally in Clearwater, Florida. BOTTOM RIGHT: A man fishes in the waters off Clearwater, Florida.Photos by Reuters/Brian Snyder

To support Trump, Lenges became a Republican. He continues to root for the president’s agenda. On a recent vacation to the Grand Canyon, he added a day to visit the U.S.-Mexico border and the wall Trump has vowed to finish.

Posing for a photo, Lenges held a poster that read: “The silent majority stands with Trump.”

WISCONSIN



RACINE COUNTY

POP. 196,584

Snow falls on a farm in Union Grove, Wisconsin.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

It’s going to take a lot of thought and a lot of persuasion this time.

Stacy Baugh, 31

Stacy Baugh would like a president attuned to the goals she sketched out in a planner in the three-bedroom apartment she shares with her cousin and their six children.

She wants job options. Ones that pay a wage she can live on, not the $13 per hour she has been earning on a hot factory line making air fresheners. She wants better schools for her children. She wants steady employment for their father despite his criminal record.

Stacy Baugh, a Democratic voter and single mother, with her four year-old daughter Mauria (L) and her eleven year-old daughter Adrinna holding her infant son Lameir beside her, speaks to Reuters at her home in Racine, Wisconsin.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

In 2016, she did not trust Trump or Democrat Hillary Clinton to deliver. So the 31-year-old Democrat skipped the presidential contest even as she cast her ballot in other races.

“Either one of them in office, there wouldn’t have been any change,” Baugh said. “So why?“

Baugh was part of an unexpected drop-off in Democratic votes in heavily African-American wards of Racine, the beleaguered Rust Best city where she is raising her four young children.

PAST PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION RESULTS

DEMOCRAT

50%

REPUBLICANRacine County45.2%49.5%2016Wisconsin46.45%47.22%Racine County51.3%47.7%2012Wisconsin52.83%45.89%Racine County53.1%45.7%2008Wisconsin56.2%42.3%Racine County47.5%51.7%2004Wisconsin49.7%49.3%

Black, bisexual and too often broke, she knows the statistics on discrimination that have some experts calling her region one of the nation’s worst for African-Americans. She has nightmares about her two sons ending up in a place like the youth prison built on a shuttered factory site near her home.

Baugh is behind on her rent. She is focused on paying her bills, interviewing for jobs, securing daycare. For now, she says, these priorities leave little time to parse the policy positions of two dozen Democrats vying to oppose Trump.

Looking for a career path, she plans to complete an information technology support program. She attended a jobs training boot camp promising decent pay at the Foxconn technology plant under construction nearby. Those jobs have not materialized, she says, leaving her to question Trump’s plan to revive American manufacturing.

LEFT: A sign marks Taiwan-based Foxconn’s facility in Mt. Pleasant, Wisconsin. RIGHT: Worshipers pray at the start of Sunday church services at Zoe Outreach Ministries in Mt. Pleasant.Photos by Reuters/Brian Snyder

Baugh cannot see herself supporting Trump in next year’s election, calling his language and actions “classless.”

An activist with get-out-the-vote groups that advocate for workers, she had more faith in politics when Barack Obama was elected America’s first black president. He disappointed her by not pardoning more non-violent offenders.

She feared worse from Clinton in 2016 given the harsh criminal sentencing law signed by her husband, former President Bill Clinton.

In 2020, she hopes to go door-to-door rallying votes for a Democrat she can believe in.

“I always go with the candidate who reaches me and touches me the most,” Baugh said. “But then nothing changes.”

PENNSYLVANIA



NORTHAMPTON COUNTY

POP. 304,807

Sixth Street leads to the center of the Slate Belt town of Bangor, Pennsylvania.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

Trump looks like he’s holding his own.

Kurt Zuhlke, 63

Kurt Zuhlke keeps an open mind about presidential politics.

He gave Obama two chances to make good on his promise to bring hope and change to America. When neither reached Zuhlke’s small town in Pennsylvania, the businessman switched allegiances to Trump.

“I wanted to throw the wrench into the gears and make sure that everybody realized that something is really wrong in this country,” Zuhlke said.

Kurt Zuhkle works with Boy Scouts from Troop 36 at their camp in the Slate Belt town of Roseto, Pennsylvania.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

He remains inclined to vote for Trump again, describing the 2020 Democratic candidates as “too old” or “too socialist.”

A Boy Scout leader, Zuhlke, 63, wishes the president would tone down his brash comments. But he gives Trump high marks for his willingness to upset the ways of Washington. He is pleased with Trump’s touch on a national economy seeing unemployment at 50-year lows. And he admires how Trump has executed his pledges to reduce industry regulations.

He wants to see people employed and making things again in Northampton County’s Slate Belt, a swath of white, working-class towns that never recovered from the demise of slate quarries and textile mills.

When Zuhlke moved here three decades ago, local Italian immigrant families welcomed him and his young family at their Sunday spaghetti dinners. “Everybody knew everybody and took care of everybody,” he said. “Not anymore.”

PAST PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION RESULTS

DEMOCRAT

50%

REPUBLICANNorthampton County46.2%50.0%2016Pennsylvania47.9%48.6%Northampton County51.7%47.0%2012Pennsylvania52.1%46.7%Northampton County55.5%43.2%2008Pennsylvania54.7%44.3%Northampton County50.1%49.0%2004Pennsylvania51.0%48.5%

Zuhlke, a Republican, has come to view Washington politicians from both parties as “ambulance chasers” who have lost touch with his community. In 2016, he said, Clinton epitomized that conceit when she called Trump’s supporters an offensive “basket of deplorables.”

Zuhlke respects the value of hard work. At age 13, he started cutting lawns. As a young adult, he washed dishes and sold insurance. He quit college upon learning he made more money than his economics professor.

He built a family-owned company into a global supplier of produce containers. He employs nine people locally, and has no interest in getting too big to keep up his golf game.

LEFT: A pedestrian and his dog pass an empty storefront in the Slate Belt town of Bangor, Pennsylvania. RIGHT: Bethlehem Mayor Robert Donchez sweeps the floor as Joe D’Ambrosio cuts hair in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania.Photos by Reuters/Brian Snyder

A sign with Zuhlke’s name is taped to a bunk bed in the cabin for Boy Scout Troop 36, where he volunteers as a way to guide the next generation. He said he will keep voting for those who offer the strong representation his community needs.

“I can go either way,” Zuhlke said. “I wanted somebody in there that could shake things up.”

ARIZONA



MARICOPA COUNTY

POP. 4,410,824

A cactus stands with various antennae on top of South Mountain in Phoenix, Arizona.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

I feel empowered.

Alexis Rodriguez, 19

When he casts his first presidential ballot next year, Alexis Rodriguez will be thinking about his Mexican mother, who works two custodial shifts a day without a vote in the country she has called home for decades.

Rodriguez was too young to participate in 2016. Now 19, he came of age politically as Trump’s conservative presidency seemed to take aim at his identities as young, gay and Latino.

“It scares me to this day, just knowing that I may be under attack,” he said.

Alexis Rodriguez speaks to Reuters at Promise Arizona’s offices in Phoenix, Arizona.Photo by Reuters/Brian Snyder

Rodriguez has never known a home beyond Phoenix, the diverse anchor of Maricopa County and population center of historically Republican Arizona. Democratic expectations for the state are rising alongside the new homes and condos remaking its desert landscape.

In 2016, Trump won Maricopa by the smallest margins of any Republican presidential candidate in years. Voters at the same time ousted their longtime sheriff, Joe Arpaio, whose anti-immigration rhetoric became a national platform for Trump.

PAST PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION RESULTS

DEMOCRAT

50%

REPUBLICANMaricopa County45.7%48.6%2016Arizona43.6%47.1%Maricopa County43.8%54.5%2012Arizona44.1%53.1%Maricopa County44.1%54.7%2008Arizona44.6%53.0%Maricopa County42.3%57.0%2004Arizona43.8%54.2%

Rodriguez, then in high school, joined classroom political discussions. He became an intern at Promise Arizona, a local nonprofit, where he helped immigrants apply for citizenship and voting rights.

Last year, he registered to vote as a Democrat, drawn to the party’s inclusive message, and cast his first ballot in the midterm congressional elections.

Emboldened by his “I voted” sticker, Rodriguez came home and rallied his older brothers to the polls, filling the household car with voters who had skipped the 2016 election. Their votes helped narrowly elect Kyrsten Sinema, a bisexual woman, as the first Arizona Democrat to win a U.S. Senate contest in three decades.

TOP: A U.S. flag is raised on the back of a Jeep at RidersUSA’s Flags for Our Fallen rally on Memorial Day in Phoenix, Arizona. BOTTOM LEFT: A daughter and her mother look out from South Mountain over Phoenix, Arizona. BOTTOM RIGHT: The security fencing at a storage facility frames a billboard reading “VOTE” in Phoenix, Arizona.Photos by Reuters/Brian Snyder

Rodriguez has now finished his freshman year studying social justice and human rights at Arizona State University, the first in his family to go to college.

On election night, he wants to watch the results arrive at home with his father, a Mexican-American veteran who shares his son’s enthusiasm for voting.

“We’re going to make sure that this country is for us,” he said. “Our voice matters.”

METHODOLOGY

The road to the White House next year runs through a handful of U.S. states where the election is expected to be especially close due to changing demographics and the polarizing politics of Republican President Donald Trump.

To better understand the dynamics driving the vote, Reuters identified four of the nation’s most competitive counties in these political battlegrounds and will report from them through the November 2020 election.

Several of the counties, like their states, swung from Democratic to Republican in the 2016 presidential contest. They reflect a variety of geographies and, according to a Reuters data analysis, populations diverse in age, education, employment and race.

They also are home to industries and issues that represent a broad cross-section of the American experience.

Though hardly the only counties that will be decisive in 2020, these four offer a window into the mood and motivations of the voters shaping the country’s political future.

Sources: State elections offices; U.S. Census Bureau; Center for American Progress; County Health Rankings & Roadmaps program at the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute

Reporting by Letitia Stein, Chris Kahn and Grant Smith
Photography by Brian Snyder
Photo editing by Travis Hartman
Design, development and graphics by Ashlyn Still and Christine Chan
Edited by Colleen Jenkins and Paul Thomasch

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

NH Politician

NH POLITICIAN is a New Hampshire based media company specializing in the collection, publication and distribution of public opinion information, local, national and world news. Our team of reporters,...